Agenda item

Observations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee on the Budget Proposals for 2022/23

To receive the observations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.

Minutes:

The Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Harrison, explained that the budget proposals for 2022/23 had been considered at the Budget Scrutiny Review Panel and the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. The meetings had been productive, but it was recognised that there was a gap of £700k and that further work would be required. The Overview and Scrutiny Committee was to consider the proposals further at its meeting on 20 January 2022. However, the proposals in general appeared to be realistic, achievable and based on sound financial practices.

 

The Committee had paid particular attention to the proposed reduction in services including the taxi voucher scheme, the reduction in the Borough News newsletter and the withdrawal of small and medium grants, as well as suggesting vacant roles be considered at the next round of budget setting. It was recognised that the Commercial Strategy would be important for the Council’s long-term financial future.

 

In response to questions from Visiting Members it was confirmed that:

·       Publicity had been undertaken in relation to the public consultation, with further publicity to take place in the New Year

·       Details of the consultation and information about how to respond were available on the Council’s website

·       The responses received during the public consultation would be considered before the final budget proposals go to Executive in January.

·       Any surplus made on commercial projects would be used to support the delivery of the Council’s services. The Council would also consider putting money back into reserves in order to fund future developments.

 

The Leader of the Council, Councillor Brunt, thanked the Budget Scrutiny Panel and the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the work that had been undertaken to scrutinise the budget proposals. The Leader also thanks officers for their work.

 

RESOLVED to note the following observations from the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in response to the Service and Financial Planning 2022/23 report:

 

1)             The national and local policy context and significant uncertainties at this stage of the budget-setting process were noted.

 

2)             The Service and Financial Planning 2022/23 report forecasts a budget gap of over £700k. In the light of this and given that assumptions and individual budgets were to be reconsidered following the December Government financial settlement announcement, the Committee did not draw a conclusion on the overall Budget proposals for 2022/23.

 

3)             The Committee requested that the final Service and Financial Planning 2022/23 report to Executive on 27 January to be an agenda item for discussion at Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 20 January.

 

4)             The Committee considered the explanations in the Budget report for year on year changes in the budget and found the following to be achievable, realistic and based on sound financial practices and reasonable assumptions, subject to the outstanding matters set out in (i) and (ii):

a)    Medium Term Financial Plan Summary

b)    Revenue Budget Savings and additional income proposals totalling £0.566m

c)    Revenue Budget Growth proposals totalling £0.567m

d)    Forecast ongoing income budget pressures in 2022/23 onwards as a consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic totalling £1.3m

e)    Revenue Reserve Balances as of 1 April 2021 of £41.738

 

5)             The Committee reviewed savings proposals in service delivery: to pause the Medium Grants and Small Grants scheme, to withdraw the taxi voucher scheme and to reduce the Borough News publication to a single issue a year, and asked they be reconsidered.

 

6)             The Committee expressed concerns about recent inflationary pressures with short term inflation well above the Bank of England 2% target which would put unbudgeted upward pressure on the cost of goods and services and on staff costs/pay demands.

 

7)             In relation to potential future cost savings the Committee supported initiatives to:

·       Assess the potential reduction of office space reflecting the impact of hybrid working.

·       Implement joint working with the boroughs and districts in East Surrey to share costs and improve services.

The Committee asked these initiatives to be accelerated.

 

8)             The Committee recommended that the need to fill vacant headcount positions be reconsidered (currently 22 full-time equivalent staff (FTE) equating to £1m salary and on-costs). These vacancies had been confirmed as part of the Service and Financial Planning reconciliation of HR establishment records and service budgets for all services.

 

9)             Implementation of the Council’s Commercial Strategy was vital to meeting budget gaps in future years, as Government funding is further reduced. Part 2 of the Commercial Strategy report was an agenda item at Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 9 December and due to be approved by Executive on 16 December. At this stage the Committee noted that no substantial additional commercial income from investments was included in the current 2022/23 budget.

 

10)          The Committee noted that the Executive intends to come forward with a Financial Sustainability Plan to be integrated with the Medium-Term Financial Plan (MTFP) in Quarter 1 2022/23

Supporting documents: